Closer to what I'd imagine a more realistic Mario looking like. Besides the eyes, I just like dot-eyes
But after all of that jumping, running, throwing Bowser, lifting ridiculously huge hammers, and more, he SHOULD have some muscle to him. Oh Nintendo logic <3. That aside, that arm. Oh my god that arm (his right, my/your left). I'm convinced I'll never get it right, so whatever. I'll deal with it.
As always, if you color it, comment below, and I'll link it below